Statement on the Smith Commission
Lord Foulkes Question
Lord Foulkes of Cumnock (Lab): My Lords, as we make progress with Scottish devolution, as we consider the clauses and as these meetings take place, do we not all agree that it will be understandable if resentment grows in England because of the English democratic deficit? If we can agree the vow effectively overnight, and if the Smith commission can be set up so quickly, why is it that the parties—the Liberal Democrats, the Conservatives and the Labour Party—cannot get together and get the UK constitutional convention up and running as quickly as possible so that we can look at the situation in the whole of the UK in a comprehensive and holistic way?
The Advocate-General for Scotland, Lord Wallace of Tankerness (LD): My Lords, I know that the noble Lord has regularly put forward the case for a UK-wide constitutional convention. As I said when your Lordships’ House debated these issues on 29 October, the Government will consider proposals for the establishment of such a convention. While it is important that we debate these things, it is also important that we engage with the wider public. Let me make it clear that today’s heads of agreements should not in any way be held up by any constitutional convention, but I am sure that there is no shortage of issues that could be sent to such a convention.
Source: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld201415/ldhansrd/text/141127-0002.htm#14112781000373
*Please note that Lord Foulkes’ question came after several other questions, and a statement from the Secretary of State for Scotland about the devolution process in Scotland, as repeated by the Advocate-General for Scotland. For a full version of the short debate, please click the link above.
Lord George Foulkes of Cumnock 